A-JMRHS Reviewer Evaluation Form

Asian Journal of Medical Research and Health Sciences
ISSN: 2583-7761 | Email: editorajmrhs@gmail.com

Manuscript ID: ________________________ Title: _________________________________________________________
Reviewer: _____________________________ Date: ________________

Section A: Overall Assessment

Please rate the manuscript on the following criteria (Excellent/Good/Fair/Poor):

Criterion	Excellent	Good	Fair	Poor
Originality & Novelty	☐	☐	☐	☐
Scientific Quality & Methodology	☐	☐	☐	☐
Significance to Field	☐	☐	☐	☐
Clarity & Presentation	☐	☐	☐	☐
Suitability for Journal	☐	☐	☐	☐

Overall Recommendation:
☐ Accept
☐ Accept with Minor Revisions
☐ Major Revisions Required
☐ Reject

Section B: Detailed Evaluation Checklist

Please indicate Yes/No and provide comments where needed.

1. Title and Abstract

Item	Yes	No	Comments
Title reflects content accurately?	☐	☐
Abstract structured & concise?	☐	☐
Keywords appropriate (MeSH terms)?	☐	☐

2. Introduction

Item	Yes	No	Comments
Problem clearly defined?	☐	☐
Literature gap justified?	☐	☐
Objectives/hypothesis clear?	☐	☐

3. Methods

Item	Yes	No	Comments
Study design appropriate?	☐	☐
Sample size justified?	☐	☐
Ethics approval stated?	☐	☐
Methods reproducible?	☐	☐
Statistical methods adequate?	☐	☐

4. Results

Item	Yes	No	Comments
Data presented clearly?	☐	☐
Tables/figures appropriate?	☐	☐
Results support conclusions?	☐	☐

5. Discussion

Item	Yes	No	Comments
Conclusions justified?	☐	☐
Limitations acknowledged?	☐	☐
Implications discussed?	☐	☐

6. General

Item	Yes	No	Comments
References current & formatted correctly?	☐	☐
Conflicts of interest declared?	☐	☐
English language quality?	☐	☐
Ethical concerns?	☐	☐
Plagiarism concerns?	☐	☐

Section C: Detailed Comments for Authors

Major Comments (issues affecting acceptance):

1. ---

2. ---

3. ---

Minor Comments (language, formatting, supplementary):

1. ---

2. ---

Section D: Confidential Comments for Editor

Strengths: _____________________________________________________________________
Weaknesses: ____________________________________________________________________
Ethical/Plagiarism Concerns: ______________________________________________________
Competing Interests: ☐ None ☐ Declare: _________________________________________

Additional Reviewers Suggested (optional):

1. Name: ________________________ Email: ________________________
2. Name: ________________________ Email: ________________________

Reviewer Signature: ___________________________ Date: ________________

Instructions:

• Complete within 14 days of assignment.
• Maintain confidentiality—do not share manuscript.
• Submit via journal system or email to editorajmrhs@gmail.com.

·        Focus comments on scientific merit; be constructive and objective.